Table 5.
MRI Studies of progressive volume change in schizophrenia (SZ)
Study | Sample | N | ROIs | Follow-up interval | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chakos et al. (1994) | First episode SZ Schizophreniform Controls |
21 8 10 |
caudate | 18 months | Increased caudate volume with typical neuroleptics. Volume correlated with dose; inversely correlated with age of onset. |
Chakos et al. (1995) | SZ | 15 | caudate | 1 year | Reduced caudate volume with atypical neuroleptics. |
Corson et al. (1999b) | Chronic SZ | 19 | caudate, lenticular nucleus | 2 years | Typical neuroleptics increase size of caudate/lenticular nucleus, atypical neuroleptics decrease size. |
SPD | 1 | ||||
Psychosis NOS | 3 | ||||
Controls | 0 | ||||
Degreef et al. (1991) | First episode SZ Controls |
13 8 |
cortical volume, ventricular volume |
1–2 years | No difference in rate of change for either.a |
DeLisi et al. (1992) | First episode SZ Controls |
50 33 |
temporal lobes, ventricular volume |
2 years | No difference in temporal lobe or ventricular volume. Change in ventricular volume was inversely correlated with amount of time in hospital for SZ. |
(Note, some subjects overlap with 1991 report, and some SZ subjects were characterized as schizophreniform or schizoaffective) |
|||||
DeLisi et al. (1995) | First episode SZ Controls |
20 5 |
cerebral hemispheres, medial temporal lobe, temporal lobe, lateral ventricles, caudate nucleus, corpus callosum |
4 years | Rate of change greater in SZ for left ventricle.a |
DeLisi et al. (1997) | First episode SZ Controls |
50 20 |
cerebral hemispheres, temporal lobe, medial temporal lobe, lateral ventricles, cerebellum, caudate nucleus, corpus callosum, Sylvian fissure |
≥ 4 years | Rate of change greater in SZ for left and right hemispheres, right cerebellum, corpus callosum segment, and ventricles.a |
DeLisi et al. (1998) | First episode SZ | 50 | cerebral hemispheres ventricles, | 5 years | Larger ventricles at baseline correlated with poorer premorbid functioning. Larger ventricles at baseline also showed less of an increase in size at follow up compared with smaller ventricles at baseline. |
Gur et al. (1998b) | SZ patients (20 first episode, 20 chronic) Controls |
40 17 |
whole brain CSF, frontal lobes, temporal lobes |
2–3 years | Rate of change of frontal lobe volume increased in SZ.a Both subject groups showed a reduction in temporal lobe volume. |
Jacobson et al. (1998) | Childhood onset SZ Controls |
10 17 |
cerebral volume, superior, anterior temporal lobe, amygdala, hippocampus |
2 years | Rate of change of total cerebral volume and temporal lobe structures increased in SZ.a |
Keshavan et al. (1998b) | First episode psychosis Controls |
17 17 |
cerebral volume, superior temporal gyrus, cerebellum |
1 year | Volume of superior temporal gyrus was inversely correlated with prodrome and psychosis duration. Rate of change of superior temporal gyrus was greater in patients.a Superior temporal gyrus volume enlarged with treatment in some patients (i.e. reversal of volume reduction after 1 year). |
Lieberman et al. (1996) | First episode SZ or schizoaffective Controls |
62 42 |
qualitative measure of lateral ventricles, third ventricle, frontal/parietal cortex, medial temporal |
18 months | Patients with poor response to treatment showed more ventricle enlargement and reduced cortical volumes compared with patients with better response to treatment. |
Nair et al. (1997) | Patients with symptoms of schizophrenia Controls |
18 5 |
total ventricular volume | 2–3 years | Rate of change greater in SZ- like patients.a |
Rapoport et al. (1997) | Childhood onset SZ Controls |
16 24 |
ventricular volume, thalamic area, caudate nucleus, putamen, globus pallidus |
2 years | Rate of change of ventricular volume and thalamic area increased in SZ.a |
Rapoport et al. (1999) | Childhood onset SZ Controls |
15 34 |
gray and white matter volume (frontal, temporal, parietal, occipital lobes |
4 years | Rate of change of gray, but not white matter in frontal, temporal, and parietal lobes increased in SZ.a |
Rate of change increased in patient group means that the structure in question changed volume at a faster rate (larger volume for given period of time) than in the control group.