Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 20;16:945398. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2022.945398

TABLE 1.

Characteristics and classification of the most cited measurement tools.

Instrument Types of assessment Type of ADL Developed for use in PD Scale has been applied to PD populations Used by other groups beyond the original developing group Clinimetric properties studied for PD population Recommendation level
MDS-UPDRS ClinRO Basic and instrumental ADL Yes Yes Yes Internal consistency, concurrent validity, face validity.
Correlation of Part II with disability measures and quality of life scales.
Recommended
S&E ADL ClinRO | PRO Not specify Yes Yes Yes Test-retest reliability, inter-rater/intra-rater reliability, minimal detectable changes, and minimal clinical important difference Recommended
Barthel ADL ClinRO | PRO Basic ADL No Yes Yes Test-retest reliability, inter-rater/intra-rater reliability, internal consistency, convergent validity Suggested
Lawton-Brody ClinRO | PRO Instrumental ADL No Yes Yes No Listed
FIM ClinRO | ObsRO Basic ADL No Yes Yes No Listed
ADCS-ADL ClinRO Basic and instrumental ADL No Yes Yes No Listed
UPDRS ClinRO Basic and instrumental ADL Yes Yes Yes Test–retest reliability (all and ADL section), inter-rater reliability, internal consistency, criterion and convergent validity.
Regarding Part II, floor and ceiling effects, convergent validity, reliability, and standard error of measurement were found to be adequate.
Recommended, but replaced by the MDS-UPDRS